| 1939, 1940 | Arthur Little (Deceased) | 1941, 1942, 1943 | George Brunton (Deceased) | |
| 1944 | Ben Bovee (Deceased) | 1945, 1946 | Charles Soch (Deceased) | |
| 1947 | Raymond Mapes (Deceased) | 1948, 1949 | Robert Brunton (Deceased) | |
| 1950 | Damon Averill (Deceased) | 1951 | Kenneth Kinsey (Deceased) | |
| 1952 | Martin Kermer (Deceased) | 1953 | Howard Compson (Deceased) | |
| 1954 | Jay Fish (Deceased) | 1955 | Russell Ward (Deceased) | |
| 1956 | Wayne Baumler (Deceased) | 1957 | Kenneth Wall (Deceased) | |
| 1958 | James Sprole (Deceased | 1959 | Harold Little (Deceased) | |
| 1960 | Floyd Law (Deceased) | 1961 | James Remmes (Deceased) | |
| 1962 | Richard Newell (Deceased) | 1963 | John Sheehan | |
| 1964 | James McFee (Deceased) | 1965 | Philip Duchscherer (Deceased) | |
| 1966 | Robert Roy (Deceased) | 1967 | James Milliron (Deceased) | |
| 1968 | M. Herbert Dusel (Deceased) | 1969 | T. Roswell Lippard (Deceased) | |
| 1970 | R. Robert Duane (Deceased) | 1971 | Robert C. Schmidt (Deceased) | |
| 1972 | Thomas F. Maguire (Deceased) | 1973 | Michael Markarian (Deceased) | |
| 1974 | Thomas Lafferty (Deceased) | 1975 | Arden R. Theobald (Deceased) | |
| 1976 | Dennis Sundholm (Deceased) | 1977 | James Huggins (Deceased) | |
| 1978 | William Mohr (Deceased) | 1979 | John F. Taggart, Jr. (Deceased) | |
| 1980 | Eugene J. Murphy | 1981 | C. Eugene Burr (Deceased) | |
| 1982 | Ed Kramer (Deceased) | 1983, 1984 | Rudy Nutz | |
| 1985 | Michael K. Murphy | 1986 | Ronald Banas | |
| 1987 | Edward H. Wargala (Deceased) | 1988 | C. Wm. Bosworth | |
| 1989 | John C. Boyce | 1990 | Henry E. Buck | |
| 1991 | Daniel J. Pruchnowski | 1992 | Ronald L. Gates | |
| 1993 | Lewis W. Smith (Deceased) | 1994 | Norman J. Stocker | |
| 1995 | Robert B. Warnock | 1996 | Charles Varco (Deceased) | |
| 1997 | William Pilkington | 1998 | Robert Dubil | |
| 1999 | Michael Matusiak | 2000 | Gary LaRussa | |
| 2001 | Larry Neutz | 2002 | David Baumler | |
| 2003 | Richard Rozicki (Deceased) | 2004 | Ronald Benson | |
| 2005 | Gary Conschafter | 2006 | Dave Fleischman (Deceased) | |
| 2007 | Tom Hauser | 2008 | Bob Zielinski | |
| 2009 | Greg Bush | 2010 | Ken Knight | |
| 2011 | Jim Ward | 2012 | Dennis McDonald | |
| 2013 | Sue Robinson (Deceased) | 2014 | Ray Ode | |
| 2015 | Kevin O’Neil | 2016 | Italo Baldassarre | |
| 2017 | Dan Brown | 2018 | Dave Krotz | |
| 2019 | Alex Dzadur | 2020 | Jose Garcia | |
| 2021 | Frank Spagnolo |